If my child could tell me: what non-speaking kids may be feeling, and how to know if therapy is helping

Short answerYour child may not use words, but they tell you things all day with their body, sounds and behavior. When behavior changes suddenly, check for pain with a doctor first. Give your child a way to communicate now, because AAC (pictures, signs, a word board or a talking app) does not stop speech from growing. Then judge therapy by your child's signals. Calmer, more communicative and free to say no are good signs. Dread, new self-injury or being forced are warning signs.
This guide is for parents of children who don't speak, or speak only a little, because of autism, speech delay, apraxia or another disability. It's practical guidance, not medical advice.
If I could tell you: an imagined voice
The lines below are not a real child's words. They are an imagined voice, based on what autistic adults and non-speaking people have written about their lives and on what research shows.
Your child may feel some of these things, or none. Use them to wonder about your child, not as a script.
If I could tell you, I'd say I may understand more than I can show you.
The lights buzz and the room is so loud it hurts. When I run, I'm running from the noise, not from you.
Sometimes my body hurts and I have no way to say where. My tummy, my teeth, my ears. So I bang my head or stop eating. That is me telling you.
When you ask me something, I need time. Please wait a little longer before you ask again.
When I flap, rock or hum, it helps me feel calm. Sometimes it means I'm happy. Please don't make me stop if it isn't hurting anyone.
Looking at your eyes can feel like too much. I can listen better when I look away.
Changes scare me when I don't know what's coming next. Show me, and I can get ready.
When nobody understands me, the frustration spills out. I'm not trying to be bad. I'm trying to be heard.
Please give me a way to talk: pictures, signs or a device. I have things to tell you too.
Ask me. Let me say no. When I'm held still and made to do it, I learn that my "no" doesn't count.
I'm not a broken version of another child. I'm me. Help me feel safe, and I can learn.
Each line rests on something real. Autistic adults describe stimming as a way to calm down and express strong feelings (Kapp et al., 2019). Many describe eye contact as uncomfortable or overwhelming (Trevisan et al., 2017).
The Autistic Self Advocacy Network says autistic people may need longer to think, find change hard, be extra sensitive to light and sound, and lose control of their body when overwhelmed (ASAN).
Not speaking doesn't mean not understanding
About 30% of autistic children stay minimally verbal even after years of support (Tager-Flusberg and Kasari, 2013). It is a very varied group, and hard to test, because most tests need a child to point or answer on request.
When one team tested word understanding in several ways, including eye-tracking and a touch screen, they found big differences between children and between methods (Plesa Skwerer et al., 2016).
In other words, a low score on one standard test may not show everything a child understands.
So here is the honest picture. Some non-speaking children understand far more than they can say. Some understand less. For many, we don't know yet.
The cause matters too. In childhood apraxia of speech, for example, the main difficulty is planning the movements for speech, not understanding (ASHA).
Presume competence
Because we can't be sure, many families choose to presume competence. You act as if your child can understand and learn, and keep giving them chances to show it. The educator Anne Donnellan called this "the least dangerous assumption."
If you assume your child understands and you're wrong, little harm is done. If you assume they don't and you're wrong, they may spend years hearing people talk about them as if they weren't there.
- Talk to your child, not about them, when they're right there.
- Tell them what will happen next, even if you're not sure they follow.
- Offer real choices, like two snacks or two shirts, and honor the one they pick.
Behavior is communication: signs your child may be in pain or unwell
When a child can't say "my tummy hurts," the pain often comes out as behavior. A consensus report in the journal Pediatrics warned doctors that in autistic people, problem behavior may be the main or only sign of a medical problem (Buie et al., 2010).
Some discomfort is also more common. A review of 15 studies found autistic children had more gut symptoms than other children, including nearly four times the odds of constipation (McElhanon et al., 2014).
The American Academy of Pediatrics lists sleep problems, feeding problems, gut symptoms and seizures among conditions that often come with autism (Hyman et al., 2020). Tooth pain and ear infections are easy to miss in any child who can't point to where it hurts.
And autistic children do feel pain, despite talk of a "high pain tolerance."
When researchers filmed young autistic children having a blood test, their faces showed strong pain reactions, and their parents' ratings didn't match well with what the camera saw (Nader et al., 2004). A child may be hurting even when they don't seem to be.
Signs that can mean pain
Researchers built a checklist for exactly this, the Non-Communicating Children's Pain Checklist (NCCPC-R). Caregivers watch for changes in sounds, face, activity, body, eating and sleeping. In children who couldn't speak, it picked up pain well (Breau et al., 2002). Signs to watch for include:
- New or more self-injury. Head-banging, hitting the jaw, cheek or ear, or biting a hand. In one study, some children with long-lasting pain hurt themselves near the place that hurt (Breau et al., 2003). Another linked self-injury with more pain behaviors day to day (Courtemanche et al., 2016).
- New aggression, crying, moaning or unusual sounds, or being harder to comfort.
- Touching, pressing or guarding one part of the body. Pressing the belly against furniture, bending over, holding the face, pulling at an ear, or flinching when touched.
- Sleep changes. Waking in the night or not settling.
- Eating changes. Refusing food, chewing on one side, or refusing to have teeth brushed.
- Toilet changes. Straining, hard poos, holding on, or soiling after being dry.
- A pained face, or pulling back from favorite things.
- Staring spells, sudden jerks or a sudden loss of skills. These can have many causes, including seizures. Film them if you safely can and show the doctor.
Overload, anxiety, meltdown or shutdown?
Not all distress is pain. Sometimes the world is simply too much. These four can look alike and often overlap.
| What you may see | What may be happening | What may help |
|---|---|---|
| Covers ears or eyes, runs from a room, hums loudly, chews on things | Sensory overload. Too much sound, light, touch, smell or movement. | Lower the input: a quieter place, dim lights, ear defenders, fewer words. |
| Paces, stims more than usual, clings, repeats the same request, can't settle | Anxiety, often about change or not knowing what comes next. | Show what comes next with pictures. Warn before changes. |
| Screams, cries, hits, throws or drops to the floor, and can't be reached by words | Meltdown. Completely overwhelmed, with a short loss of control. | Keep everyone safe. Give space, say very little and wait. Talk later, not now. |
| Goes still and silent, stares, stops answering, lies down or goes limp | Shutdown. So overwhelmed that body and mind go quiet. | Don't push for answers or tasks. Offer quiet, low demands and time. |
The National Autistic Society describes a meltdown as an intense response to being completely overwhelmed, with a temporary loss of control. It is not a tantrum or naughty behavior.
Some people withdraw instead (National Autistic Society). That quiet withdrawal, often called a shutdown, is easy to miss because the child can look "good."
A child in either state isn't choosing it, so punishment won't help. Later, look for the pattern. Was it loud, new, rushed, or near a hungry or tired time?
For a calm plan, read autism meltdowns: what helps before, during and after.
Give them a voice now: AAC
AAC (augmentative and alternative communication) means any way of communicating besides speech, such as:
- Signs and gestures, like a sign for "more" or "all done."
- Picture cards your child can hand to you or point at.
- Core-word boards with the small words people use most, like more, stop, go, help and want.
- Speech apps and devices that say a word out loud when your child taps a picture.
Does AAC stop speech from developing?
No. This is the most common worry, and the research is reassuring. In the best-designed studies, none of 27 children and adults lost speech after starting AAC, and 89% gained some, though gains were usually modest (Millar, Light and Schlosser, 2006).
A newer review in autistic children pointed the same way, although speech usually grew less than AAC use did (White et al., 2021). The American Speech-Language-Hearing Association (ASHA) says there are no prerequisites for AAC, and early AAC can help speech and language develop (ASHA).
AAC is not giving up on speech. It gives your child a voice while speech has time to grow, or for life if speech doesn't come.
Ready to start? Our AAC starter guide for parents shows how to start this week, with free picture cards.
ASHA also lists fewer challenging behaviors among AAC's goals. A child who can say "stop" or "break" doesn't have to scream it.
How to start
- Ask a speech-language pathologist (SLP) for an AAC assessment.
- Start with a few useful words like "more," "stop," "help" and "all done."
- Model it. When you talk, point to the symbols too (ASHA calls this aided language modeling). You don't need your child to copy you.
- Keep it out and within reach all day, not only at "speech time."
- Accept every try. A point, a sound, a sign or a tap all count.
Why we don't recommend facilitated communication or RPM
Facilitated communication (FC) is when a helper supports the child's hand, wrist or arm while they point to letters.
ASHA's position is that FC is discredited and should not be used, because there is extensive evidence that the messages are authored by the helper, not the person with a disability (ASHA position statement on FC). A systematic review agreed (Schlosser et al., 2014).
The Rapid Prompting Method (RPM) and Spelling to Communicate (S2C), which grew out of it, usually have a helper hold a letter board and prompt the child. ASHA does not recommend RPM, because it lacks scientific evidence and children can become dependent on the prompts.
ASHA says these messages should not be assumed to be the person's own (ASHA position statement on RPM). Small supportive studies, such as one tracking spellers' eye movements (Jaswal et al., 2020), did not test authorship with a helper who doesn't know the answer.
Helpers usually believe in these methods, and the influence is often not on purpose. But you want your child's own words. If someone else's words come out instead, your child's real needs and pain can go unheard.
Choose AAC your child can use with no one touching them or holding the board, so every message is truly theirs.
"Is this therapy helping my child?" Read your child's signals
Your child may not be able to tell you how therapy feels, but they can show you. Look at the pattern over a few weeks, not one hard day.
Good signs
- Your child goes in willingly on most days, or warms up quickly.
- They're calmer after sessions, not wound up or scared.
- They try to communicate more, in any form.
- New skills show up at home, not only in the therapy room.
- The therapist knows what upsets and soothes your child.
- Your child is allowed to say no. When they turn away or need a break, the therapist slows down or changes the plan.
- You're welcome to watch and ask why.
Warning signs
- Dread or panic before sessions, week after week.
- New self-injury, more meltdowns, new sleep problems, or lost skills since therapy started. (Check for pain with the doctor too.)
- Your child is held down, restrained or physically forced through tasks, other than to stop real danger in the moment.
- Harmless stims like flapping, rocking or humming are blocked or punished.
- Eye contact is forced.
- Your child seems "good" and compliant in sessions but flat, switched off or shut down.
- You're not allowed to watch or ask questions, or what happens in sessions is kept from you.
What "assent" means, in plain words
Assent is your child's yes, shown their own way: coming to the table, reaching for things, smiling, staying engaged.
Assent withdrawal is their no: turning away, pushing things off the table, crying, covering ears, running, going limp or going still. A child doesn't need words to say no.
In assent-based practice, the child's no is respected whether it is spoken or not (Breaux and Smith, 2023). That doesn't mean a child never does anything hard.
It means the therapist notices the no and changes something, like a break or an easier step. Pushing through a child's no again and again can teach them their signals don't matter.
If you see warning signs, you can ask questions, watch, pause therapy or get a second opinion. See how to tell if your child's therapist is good and what to expect from child therapy.
What you can do this week
- Keep a simple diary for two weeks. Note sleep, food, poos, medicines, and what happened just before each hard moment.
- Film one hard moment, if it's safe, so a doctor or therapist can see what you see.
- Book a check-up if anything changed suddenly.
- Try one AAC tool. A card for "break" or "all done," or a core-word board on the fridge. Model it all week without asking your child to use it.
- Ask the therapist three questions. "What are you working on, and why?" "How do you know when my child is upset or done, and what do you do then?" "How can we practice this at home?"
- Watch one session. Watch your child's face and body more than the tasks.
- Use a visual schedule. Show the day in pictures so changes feel less scary. Our free printable visual schedule covers mornings, after school and bedtime. TimeNinja's Family Mode shows picture steps on a phone.
- Fill in an "All about me" page. Our free autism goal sheets include one, to tell therapists and teachers what helps your child feel calm and how they ask for a break.
And be kind to yourself. You're already doing the most important thing: watching, and wondering what your child is trying to say.
The free Progress Planner has a page for your child's signals and a therapy session log, so patterns show up over weeks.
New to autism? Start with our autism in kids guide, which links every topic on this site.
Frequently asked questions
How do I know if my non-verbal child is in pain?
Look for changes from their usual behavior: new self-injury, crying, aggression, guarding or pressing one part of the body, changes in sleep or eating, or a pained face.
Autistic children do feel pain, even if they show it differently. When behavior changes suddenly, see your child's doctor and ask them to check for causes like constipation, teeth, ears and seizures.
Will AAC stop my child from talking?
No. Research reviews have found that AAC does not reduce speech, and many children gain some speech after starting it. ASHA says early AAC can help speech and language develop. It gives your child a voice now, while speech has time to grow.
Why does my child hit their head?
There can be many reasons: pain (from ears, teeth or a headache, for example), frustration at not being understood, or sensory overload. Research links self-injury with pain in children who can't speak.
If head-hitting is new or getting worse, see your child's doctor first, and keep your child safe while you look for the cause.
Is RPM or spelling to communicate real?
ASHA does not recommend the Rapid Prompting Method (RPM) because it lacks scientific evidence, and says its messages should not be assumed to be the person's own.
Spelling to Communicate (S2C) grew out of RPM and raises the same concerns. Choose AAC your child can use without anyone touching them or holding the board, so you know the words are theirs.
How do I know if my autistic child is happy in therapy?
Watch their signals over a few weeks. Good signs: going in willingly most days, calmer afterwards, communicating more, new skills at home, and being allowed to say no.
Warning signs: dread before sessions, new self-injury or lost skills, being held down or forced, stims stopped, forced eye contact, or a child who is compliant but shut down.
What is the difference between a meltdown and a shutdown?
Both can happen when a child is overwhelmed. In a meltdown, it comes out: screaming, crying, hitting or dropping to the floor.
In a shutdown, it goes inward: the child goes quiet and still or stops responding. Neither is naughty behavior. Both need safety, quiet and time.
Sources
- Tager-Flusberg H, Kasari C. Minimally verbal school-aged children with autism spectrum disorder: the neglected end of the spectrum. Autism Res, 2013.
- Plesa Skwerer D, et al. Comparing methods for assessing receptive language skills in minimally verbal children and adolescents with autism spectrum disorders. Autism, 2016.
- American Speech-Language-Hearing Association. Childhood apraxia of speech (Practice Portal).
- Donnellan AM. The criterion of the least dangerous assumption. Behavioral Disorders, 1984.
- Kapp SK, et al. "People should be allowed to do what they like": autistic adults' views and experiences of stimming. Autism, 2019.
- Trevisan DA, et al. How do adults and teens with self-declared autism spectrum disorder experience eye contact? A qualitative analysis of first-hand accounts. PLoS One, 2017.
- Autistic Self Advocacy Network. About autism.
- Buie T, et al. Evaluation, diagnosis, and treatment of gastrointestinal disorders in individuals with ASDs: a consensus report. Pediatrics, 2010.
- McElhanon BO, et al. Gastrointestinal symptoms in autism spectrum disorder: a meta-analysis. Pediatrics, 2014.
- Hyman SL, Levy SE, Myers SM, AAP Council on Children with Disabilities. Identification, evaluation, and management of children with autism spectrum disorder. Pediatrics (American Academy of Pediatrics clinical report), 2020.
- Nader R, et al. Expression of pain in children with autism. Clin J Pain, 2004.
- Breau LM, et al. Psychometric properties of the non-communicating children's pain checklist-revised. Pain, 2002.
- Breau LM, et al. Relation between pain and self-injurious behavior in nonverbal children with severe cognitive impairments. J Pediatr, 2003.
- Courtemanche AB, et al. The relationship between pain, self-injury, and other problem behaviors in young children with autism and other developmental disabilities. Am J Intellect Dev Disabil, 2016.
- National Autistic Society. Meltdowns: a guide for all audiences.
- Millar DC, Light JC, Schlosser RW. The impact of augmentative and alternative communication intervention on the speech production of individuals with developmental disabilities: a research review. J Speech Lang Hear Res, 2006.
- White EN, et al. Augmentative and alternative communication and speech production for individuals with ASD: a systematic review. J Autism Dev Disord, 2021.
- American Speech-Language-Hearing Association. Augmentative and alternative communication (Practice Portal).
- American Speech-Language-Hearing Association. Facilitated communication (position statement). 2018.
- American Speech-Language-Hearing Association. Rapid Prompting Method (position statement). 2018.
- Schlosser RW, et al. Facilitated communication and authorship: a systematic review. Augment Altern Commun, 2014.
- Jaswal VK, et al. Eye-tracking reveals agency in assisted autistic communication. Sci Rep, 2020.
- Breaux CA, Smith K. Assent in applied behaviour analysis and positive behaviour support: ethical considerations and practical recommendations. Int J Dev Disabil, 2023.